Karan Thapar calling for removal of Modi / why

'MODIFICATION' OF POLITICS: Sudden removal of Modi
Karan Thapar
December 29, 2007
The Hindustan Times

Narendra Modi's stunning victory will change Indian politics decisively, perhaps dramatically, possibly desperately. I have no doubt it's a turning point. Actually, it will amount to several turning points. For the Congress and for the Left, just as much as for the BJP and the NDA.

First the BJP. Nothing has galvanised the party so comprehensively since Advani's rathyatra of 1989, imbuing it with a sense of hope, even a sense of purpose. In Modi, the BJP has discovered three elements it was anxiously searching for -- leadership, issues to stand for and the first hope that it can win a majority on its own.

Of course, Advani will continue as its prime ministerial candidate, but Modi is the future. The
succession is settled. No other second generation leader can match him. And as for the argument that Modi cannot take centrestage in Delhi because the NDA allies won't accept him, the counter is that with Modi at the helm, the BJP could attempt to win on its own. The NDA may no longer be critical.

The key question is can Moditva work outside Gujarat? It depends on how you define it. If you believe it combines strong personal leadership and integrity, with an appeal to regional pride or robust nationalism -- admittedly with strong communal undertones -- and a stress on development, I see no reason why it can't translate throughout the country. Even the fact that it alienates minorities is counterbalanced by div the promise of uniting Hindus as never before. And if in Gujarat it could cut across divisions of caste, wealth and location, then it can hope to do so elsewhere as well. Modi and Moditva is, therefore, the facing the Congress, the UPA and the Left. I don't deny it has to be fought ideologically, but that also calls for the projection of a single personality who, in herself, embodies the fight. She has to rival Modi's appeal --both his magnetism and his myth -- and symbolise the alternate vision.

Perhaps there is only one person who can do that. The pronoun 'she' was used deliberately. It's Sonia Gandhi. It may be an irony that an Italian-born woman, a widow who till 1998 detested politics, should transform into one of the twin poles of Indian politics, but it could also be an inescapable fact. No other person from the anti-BJP parties has the appeal or the nation-wide to rival Modi.

Only the sudden removal of Narendra Modi can stop this. For he is the agent forcing this change. And whilst he's with us, he will do just that. I have no doubt Indian politics after Sunday the 23rd is another country. We have to live with new challenges. Some of us have to accept new leaders.